Rashid Hussain

2019-11-03 09:07:03.0


Greetings for the day!
Although I have never got a response for any of my mails, here I am raising another anomalous issue which needs to be authenticated for it's veracity or falsity:

"Gandhiji took a vote of Pradesh Congress Committee (PCC) presidents in 1946, and only one of the 16 PCC Presidents voted for Nehru. The other 15 voted for Sardar Patel. But Gandhiji asked Patel to withdraw in favour of Nehru for practical politics ?  to hasten British departure- Subramanian Swamy (https://scroll.in/article/685571/four-facts-about-sardar-patel-that-modi-would-find-disappointing)"

"A perusal of Congress party documents shows that despite Gandhiji having made his choice known, 12 of 15 state committees nominated Patel for party president." - MAKKHAN LAL  (https://theprint.in/opinion/jawaharlal-nehrus-election-as-indias-first-prime-minister-wasnt-unanimous/34519/)

Have been trying to ascertain the fact about this which even big media houses have reported, but could not find anything authentic till now.

Request you to please delve into this and bring about the truth.

This may help:

"This, as you may know, is an extremely popular tale on the internet. As you also might know, Pradesh Congress Committees voting to elect the prime minister is an absurd proposition ? a bit like Modi getting elected by BJP state units.

A variant of this conspiracy theory is that the Pradesh Congress Committees thought they were electing the Congress president (and not the prime minister). But the Congress president at the time of Independence somehow became prime minister (the exact process is never explained). Problems here too: Pradesh Congress Committees don’t elect Presidents, delegates of the All India Congress Committee do. Moreover, Nehru was not the Congress President when India gained independence, JB Kripalani was. Tragically, no one informed Kripalani of this mechanism and he remained bereft of prime ministership right until his dying day.

The simple reason as to why Nehru became PM was that he was, by far, the Congress’ most popular politician (after Gandhi, of course). Right from the 1937 provincial elections, Nehru was the party’s star campaigner, enthralling crowds with his Hindustani oratory. Patel had an iron grip on the Congress party itself but he was many miles behind Nehru as a popular leader. The Sardar himself conceded this: at a massively attended Congress rally in Mumbai, he told American journalist Vincent Sheean, “They come for Jawahar, not for me.”

Thus, in 1946, when the Viceroy formed his interim government, Nehru was, unsurprisingly, given the highest post. Later, on August 15, 1947, he naturally took office as prime minister, without the least opposition from anyone in the Congress.
" (https://scroll.in/article/685571/four-facts-about-sardar-patel-that-modi-would-find-disappointing)


Rashid Hussain  

Fact Hunt's Response


Recent Comments

Support Fact Hunt

We need your support to survive in the industry.

Sign Up For Our Newsletters.

Get our articles in your email as soon as it goes live!
Error! Please Try Again.

Other Rumours

Sign Up For Our Newsletters.

Get our articles in your email as soon as it goes live!
Error! Please Try Again.


Fact Hunt is a community driven social platform. If you find any rumours on social media, then you can submit it on Fact Hunt.
Login to submit